I’m sure all of you have heard stories about the
Governor’s budget plan. Always remember, “One side seems right
until you’ve heard the other side.�
Government has gotten itself into
great trouble by not dealing with spending issues in the past.
For example, last year all government workers got a 3% pay raise
in a bad recession. Why? It bought votes for politicians even
when they knew they couldn’t afford it.
What the Governor
has done this year has not been done for a very long time. There
will be many departments begging not to get cut and asking for
someone else to take the hit or taxes to be raised for their
benefit. State workers get benefits, retirements, and pay beyond
what the private sector gets, yet will beg for more. Teachers
will say it’s all about the kids but it’s really about their pay
and benefits since 85% to 90% of the K-12 budget is teacher pay
and benefits. Benefits that are well beyond what Michigan can
afford and beyond what those paying for them can themselves
afford. While we all appreciate and value the jobs these groups
do, the current structure is simply unsustainable.
Here’s a quick summary of the
Governor's budget:
1. A $1.4 billion
deficit looming for the state − he addresses it.
2. Our Michigan
Business Tax plus its surcharge and regulatory structure stink
for businesses that want to come to or stay in Michigan − he
eliminates it. This will be replaced by a fair and simple flat
6% tax for all corporations.
3. A 4.9% cut to
K-12 budgets. If every teacher agreed to benefit and minor pay
reductions no teacher needs be laid off or class sizes
increased.
4. A 15% cut to
universities, with extra money given to those that find ways to
be efficient and don’t raise tuition above certain levels. Ask
yourself why same sex benefits are being paid against the
Supreme Court ruling if money is so tight, and how many hours
each professor actually spends in the classroom teaching. There
are savings to be had.
5. Lifetime limit of
48 months on cash assistance for welfare recipients, with some
hardship exceptions.
6. Elimination of
the EITC (Earned Income Tax Credit). Much of this is not earned
or paid by the individuals receiving it. Most simply get more
back than they paid in taxes in the first place, plus possibly
receiving other welfare benefits.
7. Saving in the
Department of Corrections. Savings can be found by closing
inefficient prisons, allowing competitive bidding of food
service and prison stores, and eliminating some state police
buildings while keeping the officers.
8. Reduction in the
personal income tax from 4.35% to 4.25%.
9. Elimination of
the tax exemption on private and public pensions. I’ll look at
this closely as well. The rationale is that people with 401(k)
plans and other retirement savings all pay taxes when
withdrawing from those accounts, as do private pensioners over a
certain rate. On the other hand, state and federal pensions are
not taxed at all. The Governor indicates that the tax will not
directly impact incomes that do not eclipse $40,000 per year.
10. Increase of
$25.5 million in constitutional revenue sharing over the current
year, but eliminate statutory revenue sharing for cities,
villages, and townships. It will be replaced with $200 million
that will be available to municipalities that adopt best
practices to achieve savings. County revenue sharing will be
appropriated at $100 million, a reduction of $14 million.
11. The budget
assumes $180 million of employee concessions by state workers.
12. Elimination of
six trial court judgeships in the Judiciary budget, thanks to
case load reductions.
13. Cuts film
incentives to only $25 million. I want them eliminated
completely because our 42% kickback to that industry is losing
money every time a movie comes to Michigan.
14. Increases to $25
million the funding for Pure Michigan advertising. Like the film
tax credits, I don’t believe this pays for itself. If it did,
the hotels, ski resorts, etc. would be advertising themselves
and taxpayers wouldn’t have to do it. I already voted against
this portion of the plan in early February.
15. Adds $25 million
to attract new businesses to Michigan and $25 million for
entrepreneurial activities.
16. The budget will
be done by May 31 and an estimated budget for 2013 will be done
at the same time. If this happens, Michigan will be one of the
best states to do business in, drawing job providers back to
Michigan. Our state as already gotten kudos from the Wall Street
Journal for attacking spending and getting our fiscal house in
order. This should bring our bond rating back to AAA, which
means we pay less debt interest.
The new director of
the Michigan Department of Human Services notified me that my
suggestion to stop giving certain college students Bridge Cards
(food stamps) saved the taxpayers $48 million. Michigan was not
abiding by federal standards, making it so that any student
attending college with “an approved education plan� would be
eligible to receive assistance. I believe strongly that our
assistance programs need to be upheld with integrity to reduce
abuse of the system and ensure that only those truly in need
receive aid. Additionally, working directly with the director of
the department, we were able to make the change quickly and
without the need for legislation. The changes will be effective
as of April 1st
2011.
As your state
representative, I look forward to finally shrinking the size of
government and getting our spending under control so we can all
keep more of our own income instead of working for the
government half of our lives. I will also continue to attempt to
stop illegal immigration into our state so our jobs go to legal
Michigan residents.